Bowls plan tracks

MELVILLE’S new deputy mayor has failed to put the brakes on the Melville Bowling and Recreation Club redevelopment.

Cr Nicole Robins moved an alternative motion at the November 17 council meeting seeking to halt further investment until councillors had considered the City’s proposed leasing and licensing policy and examined whether sporting clubs had equitable opportunities to generate commercial income from City-owned facilities.

But colleagues rejected the delay, endorsing the investigation of refurbishment or rebuilding in the existing location.

Cr Robins argued the leasing arrangements, particularly the proposed commercial sublease to a padel operator, needed to be resolved before the City committed to a redevelopment pathway.

• Revamp or replace? Melville Bowling Club’s old clubhouse needs work either way.

“The decision that we make about how the facility is refurbished or redeveloped, as is the officer recommendation this evening, needs to come after the decision about the subleasing terms and conditions,” she said.

The bowling club has entered into arrangements with Future Padel for up to six courts, with a proposed annual sublease payment of about $40,000.

Cr Robins questioned whether other clubs had comparable opportunities to generate commercial income.

“If the Melville Bowling Club might generate $40,000 or $60,000 per annum from from the padel, but if the Leeming Bowling Club doesn’t have the opportunity to derive that kind of commercial income, is that fair? 

“And if not, what are we doing about it?”

Cr Glenys Barber opposed the delay, arguing the feasibility study would examine the very management and financial arrangements Cr Robins wanted investigated. She said waiting for the leasing policy to undergo community consultation could delay the project for months and disadvantage the clubs using the facility.

“Why are we picking on clubs who are trying to be sustainable in the future?” she said.

Cr Barber said the bowling club and Perth Saints Football Club had developed a valuable partnership, with the Saints having more than 800 members and the bowling club about 450.

“They’re bursting at the seams, and they’re loving the relationship they’ve got with the Melville Bowling Club,” she said.

“Why are we picking on the Melville Bowling Club?”

The existing clubhouse, built in 1957/58, is structurally sound but has accessibility, layout and amenity limitations.

Preliminary estimates put refurbishment at $7.92 million, compared with $11.23 million for demolition and rebuilding. A further $477,250 in maintenance, defect and capital works has been identified over three years if the existing building is retained.

Cr Barber said the feasibility investigation was already covered by the City’s $168,000 planning budget.

“This is already budgeted. They are not asking us for money,” she said.

The study will examine the three options, along with future management arrangements, revenue opportunities, parking, environmental constraints and the relationship between the bowling club, Perth Saints and the wider Tompkins Park and Atwell precinct.

Its findings will return to council before any decision on construction or capital funding. No redevelopment funding is currently included in the City’s Long-Term Financial Plan.

by STEVE GRANT

Leave a Reply