Hall lease battle heats up

A SRI LANKAN Islamic association says it received assurances about a five-year lease renewal on Beaufort Park Hall from Bayswater council staff before a petition with Islamphobic undertones saw it suddenly facing eviction.

The increasingly bitter dispute has pitted the Association of Sri Lankan Australian Muslims WA against neighbours who say they have been locked out of their own community hall for eight years, with a council agenda briefing last week exposing tensions over religion and the use of public facilities.

AUSLAM president Muzahir Mohideen told councillors the organisation had proposed extending the building to accommodate its growing membership, but withdrew the application when it became clear it lacked support.

He said AUSLAM then entered direct negotiations with the City over its lease and was given assurances that a five-year extension would be possible.

“It was signed and sent back,” he said in response to a question from councillors.

But following a petition signed by 590 residents opposing the lease renewal, AUSLAM found itself facing a very different situation, with the City proposing just 18 months before it would have to vacate the hall.

Mr Mohideen said the relocation would inevitably disrupt important support services, arguing that AUSLAM could not simply move into another hall because it needed suitable premises with storage, accessibility and privacy for sensitive family support work.

He took the City to task for not discussing its compromise solution with AUSLAM before putting it to the council.

The organisation has requested 30 months to find premises, secure approvals and progressively relocate its operations.

In a deputation, AUSLAM secretary Imran Iqbal told councillors the organisation was entirely volunteer-run and received no government funding, providing food relief, mental health support, migrant settlement assistance, youth mentoring and activities for women, seniors and families.

Compliance

He said the organisation had achieved 94 per cent compliance across its last three annual lease audits, and increased the hall’s utilisation from 11.5 per cent to 71 per cent.

“We respectfully urge the council not to support option one, which was also part of the report that was submitted, where the lease is expiring on January 31, 2027. 

“We only have approximately nine weeks remaining. 

“This is simply not enough time to relocate an organisation supporting vulnerable families,” he said.

Mr Iqbal said AUSLAM was seeking the City’s assistance to identify alternative premises and would leave earlier if suitable accommodation could be secured.

But neighbouring resident Pauline Basso said the organisation had effectively taken over a facility intended to be shared with the wider community.

She argued the original 2018 council decision to grant AUSLAM a lease included a requirement that it make the hall available to other community groups, but that clause was omitted when officers drafted the agreement.

Ms Basso said residents had subsequently found themselves unable to hire the hall, despite the City’s website continuing to advertise it for casual use.

“We are welcoming to outsiders. AUSLAM is not,” she told councillors.

She said the petition was not an attempt to exclude AUSLAM but to restore the hall’s original purpose as a community facility.

Ms Basso said that while doorknocking for the petition, only four people had asked which organisation occupied the hall, and only one had subsequently asked what religion it followed after being told it was a religious organisation.

She rejected suggestions the campaign was motivated by opposition to Islam, saying residents were happy for AUSLAM to remain part of the community, provided it shared the facility with others.

The meeting took a more uncomfortable turn when resident Iris Barnes raised concerns about the organisation’s religious activities.

“The teaching of Islam is also a great concern to most Australians, as it is not what Australia is about,” she said.

Cr Nat Latter subsequently called on mayor Filomena Piffaretti to explain why Ms Barnes had not been challenged over the statement.

The mayor responded that she had been “fair”.

AUSLAM supporter Shafqa Nazeem said the hall had become an important meeting place for families, particularly mothers with young children who might otherwise feel isolated.

Her children had attended AUSLAM’s after-school programs for six years and had formed lasting friendships, she said.

by STEVE GRANT

Leave a Reply